Religious delegation visits ‘Tent City’

religious delegation to tent city

The Rev. Leslie Takahashi Morris and the Rev. Susan Frederick Gray were part of a delegation of religious leaders who visited “Tent City.” Photo © 2012 Dea Brayden/UUA

Unitarian Universalist Association President Peter Morales said he was “saddened and appalled” by what he observed inside the Tent City jails, an outdoor jail complex maintained by Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio.

Arpaio led Morales on a tour of a women’s and a men’s jail Saturday evening. He was accompanied by the Rev. Geoffrey A. Black, president of the United Church of Christ, the Rev. Dr. William Schulz, president of the UU Service Committee, the Rev. Susan Frederick Gray, minister of the UU Congregation of Phoenix, and the Rev. Leslie Takahashi Morris, minister of the Mt. Diablo UU Church in Walnut Creek California.

Arpaio greeted the visitors outside the Estrella Jail, a women’s facility enclosed in tall chain-link fence topped with concertina wire. Parked outside the entrance was a black tank emblazoned with the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office logo. A sign on the fence said, “Tent City. 19 Years. 437,946 ‘served’ time.”

Complaints of cruel and unusual punishment have been lodged against the outdoor complex since it opened. In the desert heat, temperatures in the tents have reportedly reached into the 130s. Tent City has been condemned by numerous human rights organizations, including Amnesty International USA, which Schultz previously led. “There is fundamentally no excuse for keeping people out in this heat,” said Schulz. “It is a violation of international standards and of fundamental human decency.”

Arpaio led the delegation through the gates of the women’s jail. Gravel walkways separated concert slabs covered by army-green tents. Under the tents were rows of metal bunk beds.

Inmates approached the visitors, dressed in black-white-striped pants and shirts with “Sheriff’s Inmate” written in block letters across the back. They wore the jail’s trademark pink socks.

The group also wound through an attached men’s facility, called Tents Jail, where inmates also wore pink socks. Some men could be seen in pink boxer shorts. Many had pink ID bracelets around their wrists.

Prisoners swarmed around the visitors, trying to quickly relate a list of grievances as guard urged the visitors along. Inmates spoke of “horrible” food that contained maggots and rocks. A kitchen worker said ingredients were often expired, and the kitchen was inhabited by roaches and rats. They had no cold water, several said. A man told of a dust storm recently gusting through the encampment. The inmates were not allowed to put down their tent flaps, and dust stung his eyes. “Why couldn’t they put the tent flaps down?” a visitor asked. “They’re just mean,” the inmate said. “They pick on us.”

View this slideshow on UU World‘s Flickr page. Created with Admarket’s flickrSLiDR.

Not all complained. One male inmate said, “It’s not the Holiday Inn, but I’m not suffering.” Some women spoke of how they like working on the female chain gang. The group leaves the facility to pick up trash. On Thursdays, a member of the chain gang said, they dig graves for the indigent.

As Arpaio walked through, many inmates approached him with postcards and asked him to sign them. They bear pictures of inmates and the tents, and have slogans on them such as “Hello from Sunny Arizona!” and “Keep America Beautiful!” above a picture of the female chain gang at work. Some inmates send the postcards home to their families. One man had his signed for his grandmother, whom he said is a big fan of Tent City. A woman who will soon be released said she had hers signed as a personal reminder that she didn’t want to come back.

Guards were positioned near the perimeter fences with shotguns. They were loaded with “less than lethal rounds,” an officer explained.

In the mess hall, Arpaio showed examples of the two meals a day that inmates are served. He unwrapped a “brunch,” which he said was served around 11 am. It contained slices of turkey, oranges, rolls, and cookies. A dinner plate was heaped with a brown gruel, called soy lentil stew. Beside it, were broccoli, apple sauce, a roll, and cookies. Several dinner plates were laid on the metal tables, and Arpaio urged visitors to try the food. Morales ate a forkful of stew, as did Arpaio.“It’s a good recipe,” Arpaio said, later adding, “It’s a little bland. It could use some salt.”

Arpaio said that he soon plans to begin charging inmates for their meals, likely $1 a day.

In the Mess Hall, Arpaio responded dismissively to any and all accusations from the visiting delegation. Schultz asked about the reports of maggots. Arapio waved his hand and said you could find that in restaurant kitchens.

Morales asked about the $50 million Arizona taxpayers have paid out in lawsuits against the Sheriff’s office relating to civil rights violations and jail conditions since Arpaio became sheriff in 1993. Arpaio said it was more like $30 million, and that’s the “nature of doing business.” He urged visitors to compare the numbers to other agencies to be fair.

“Do you think you’re treated unfairly?” Morales asked.

“It goes with the territory,” said Arpaio. He later added that he is accountable to the people of Maricopa County and has been reelected five times.

After the tour, Arpaio and the delegation held a press conference outside the jail gates. Morales said, “I am saddened and appalled that this kind of thing happens in my country. It is degrading and mean.”

Black, of the UCC, said “Over the years, I’ve visited inmates thoughout the country. I’ve never seen anything like this. . . . It hurts me to think this has gone on as long as it has. More people should visit this place to see what is going on. I don’t think they would feel this is justice as we understand it.”

Schulz was questioned about how the jail compared to others he has visited internationally. He reiterated how the excessive heat violates international conventions. “China is in violation. Myanmar is in violation. And Maricipa County is in violation,” he said.

Takahashi Morris said, “As I looked in the eyes of the inmates, I couldn’t help thinking about my father’s family held in an interment in Poston, Arizona,” she said, referring to the Japanese internment camps during World War II. “They were also put in inhumane conditions in the name of safety.”

“No person should be housed in the heat of the desert in a tent,” said Frederick-Gray. “We have been asleep to allow Tent City to be here for 20 years.” She said the culture of cruelty that has allowed Tent City to exist has also led to unjust laws such as Arizona’s S.B. 1070.

  • http://www.facebook.com/lauren.davistodd Lauren Davis-Todd

    Rev. Morales, I have a few questions and as a UU, I would like your answers, because I have read so many differing comments about tent city. Are there any fans in the tents? Can a person even survive in 130 degree heat? Did you taste the food? Was there evidence of rats and vermin? Did you feel that some of the inmates were afraid to speak up? How do you account for all the discrepancies in the stories that are published? How are the inmates subjected to cruel and unusual punishment, other than the heat? Do you think giving the men pink clothing is meant to take away their dignity? Do any inmates confirm this? Were any inmates asked about this? What specifically constitutes the “culture of cruelty” spoken of by Rev. Gray? I am really yearning to understand this situation and have been so confused by so many accounts, such as the comparison of tent city to concentration camps in Nazi Germany. Exactly what are your suggestions to make tent city humane? Thank you very much for your thoughts.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1274890366 Chris Grepo

    Wow… This is a prison, not Club Med! The sheriff should be receiving a raise for placing harsher punishment for criminals that deserve the punishment. I survived in the 130 degree heat in Iraq… That’s not what is going to kill anybody there. We have to remember, prison is not a vacation, and these guys and gals are not on our streets anymore. Good job sheriff Arpaio! Shame on you Peter Morales, Rev Shultz, Rev Gray, and the rest of you for criticizing a system that has proven to work! People should fear going to prison. That is a consequence for breaking the law! Without justice there is no order! Don’t poke your libral nose where it doesn’t belong!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1274890366 Chris Grepo

    If you can’t do the time, don’t commit the crime!

  • http://www.facebook.com/kazia.mermel Kazia Mermel

    No one deserves to be treated so inhumanely, not even a criminal. What’s more, the majority of the people in tent city are not even close to dangerous criminals. Some of them have been incarcerated as a result of crimes as minor as having a dead tail-light. Is this justice?

  • http://www.facebook.com/eric.bliss.18 Eric Bliss

    You have an exceedingly narrow view sir. It must be incredibly comfortable to live in such a black and white world. Too bad that world doesn’t exist. “These guys and gals are not on our streets anymore.” Ugh, these immigrants came to America for a better shot, a better life. Sound familiar? Yeah, your ancestors did the same thing. Where would you be had they been turned away? Empathy dude. Try it for a minute, and then you might see that the world isn’t so starkly dichotomous.

  • http://www.facebook.com/cindiequilts Cindie White-Weiss

    This is in no way a prison. It’s an interment camp.

  • http://twitter.com/PhoenixWomanMN Phoenix Woman

    Arpaio’s pretending that Latino immigrants are the problem when the real problem is the violence caused by our insane drug laws that have turned much of Mexico into an ungovernable narcostate whose drug lords seem to have a symbiotic relationship with “tough guys” like Arpaio.

  • R.L. Randall

    This is not a prison. Let’s call it what it is … a slave camp. Sheriff Arpaio has enslaved Latinos for the good of Maricopa County or at least that is what he will tell you. Sheriff Arpaio should recite the Pledge of Allegiance keeping in mind the part about; one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all. The beauty of the Pledge is that it ends with liberty and justice for all, not all Americans, but all. There is no liberty, no justice in tent city, just Sheriff Arpaio’s slave camp where Master Arpaio thinks he’s God!

  • http://www.facebook.com/sara.lawall Sara LaWall

    It is not a prison, it is a jail. There is a difference. And, this
    place is being used as a detention facility for immigration violations
    which are civil violations not criminal ones. So lets’ be clear about
    our terms and populations. But regardless of who the inmates are and
    what violations got them here, there are some maximum security prisons
    that hold murderers who are treated better than these people with lesser
    offenses. It is a violation of human rights to deny any people (prisoners or not) access to food
    that meets a minimum standard and to subject them to excessive heat and
    temperatures. If we are meant to e a leader in the the free world and
    hope to have other countries look up to us then we had better start
    acting like it, Because if we continue to treat human beings this way
    we condone far worse treatment by many other countries who abuse basic
    human rights.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Charles-Wiggenhorn/1684316983 Charles Wiggenhorn

    I think Sheriff Joe’s doing great work. I only wish we could hire him away to run the Orleans Parish prison.

GENERAL ASSEMBLY

Previous Coverage

PUBLISHED BY

UUA logo

Unitarian Universalist Association
24 Farnsworth Street
Boston MA 02210-1409
617-948-6502

www.uua.org